snitch.el (pronounced like schnitzel) is a firewall for Emacs. snitch intercepts calls to create network connections or launch subprocesses. Through user-configured default policies, filter rules, and user hooks it is able to log and potentially block each action. It can be configured with ‘M-x customize-group snitch’. Subprocesses and network connections are handled independently, with their own separate default policies, blacklist and whitelist, and logging policies. The main purpose of snitch is network monitoring. Subprocesses are included because it is extremely common for Emacs packages to "shell out" to an external program for network access, commonly to ‘curl’. As a side effect, snitch can also effectively audit and prevent undesired access to other programs. Notifications can be raised on each logged event by ensuring the ’alert’ package is installed and customizing ‘snitch-enable-notifications’ to t. === WHY? === Emacs is a general-purpose execution environment, executing with the full privileges of whichever user launched it. It can read and create files, obviously, but also spawn external programs, open network connections, and communicate through pipes. In modern times, most users manage large collections of third-party packages through intelligent package managers that automatically pull in any number of dependencies, updated periodically. Any and all of these could be a bit naughty, and the sheer quantity of Lisp code in a modern Emacs install makes it un-auditable. An Emacs firewall, thus, makes sense. Does *snitch* make sense? Not really... see the SECURITY section below. But we currently have nothing, and snitch is better than nothing. Also, to answer the question: "I wonder if I can make an Emacs firewall?" Yes! ...well, sort of. === MECHANISM === The underlying ’firewall’ mechanism is built on function advice surrounding Emacs’s lowest-level core functions for spawning connections or subprocesses. When an Emacs package or script makes such a request, snitch receives it first, and either passes it through or rejects it based on the current rules. Once a connection or process is accepted, snitch is no longer involved for the duration of that particular communication stream. For each intercepted call, snitch first builds an event object defining everything snitch knows about the call. The metadata differs for network connections (host, port, family) and processes (executable and argument list), but all events share a common set: calling function, calling function’s file path, calling package, and request name. Once an event object is created, it is passed to any hooks defined in ‘snitch-on-event-functions’ for early processing. If a hook returns nil, the event is dropped immediately. Otherwise, snitch then checks the corresponding whitelist (if the default policy is deny) or the blacklist (if the default policy is allow) and makes its internal decision. Before executing the decision, it calls the corresponding hook functions to give the user hooks one more opportunity to change the decision. Finally, only if the decision was ‘allow’, snitch executes the original request and passes the result back to the caller. As the event flows through the decision tree, it also triggers log events. There are several different types defined in ‘snitch-log-policies’, and users can subscribe to any combination of them by customizing ‘snitch-log-policy’. Logs are displayed in text format in a dedicated log buffer (by default: ‘*snitch firewall log*’), along with text properties that allow extracting the event information programatically from a log line with ‘get-text-property’. The text lines can be "pretty printed" by customizing ‘snitch-log-verbose’. An example log entry is below, split to several lines for display. In the actual log, non-verbose logs are a single line. > [2020-12-03 00:16:50] (whitelisted) -- #s(snitch-network-entry \ > 1606951010.2966838 helm-M-x-execute-command \ > /home/trevor/.emacs.d/elpa/helm-20201019.715/helm-command.el \ > helm 127.0.0.1 127.0.0.1 64222 nil) With `snitch-log-verbose' enabled, log entries actually do take several lines: > [2020-12-03 01:11:27] (blocked) -- > (snitch-network-entry "snitch-network-entry-157d34506664" > > :timestamp 1606954287.770638 > :src-fn snitch--wrap-make-network-process > :src-path "/home/trevor/.emacs.d/snitch/snitch.el" > :src-pkg user > :proc-name "google.com" > :host "google.com" > :port 80) === GETTING SNITCH === snitch is published in the MELPA package repository. The recommend installation method is via an Emacs package manager that supports MELPA. use-package: > (use-package snitch :ensure t) straight.el: > (straight-use-package 'snitch) manually: > (require 'package) > (add-to-list 'package-archives > '("melpa" . "https://melpa.org/packages/")) > (unless (package-installed-p 'snitch) > (package-install 'snitch)) > (require 'snitch) It can also be installed by any package manager that supports git repositories, or manually via tarball. quelpa: > (quelpa '(snitch :repo "mrmekon/snitch-el" :fetcher github)) use-package + quelpa + quelpa-use-package: > (use-package snitch > :quelpa (snitch :repo "mrmekon/snitch-el" :fetcher github)) el-get: > (el-get-bundle mrmekon/snitch-el) straight.el: > (straight-use-package > '(snitch :type git :host github :repo "mrmekon/snitch-el")) manual: > (package-install-file "/path/to/snitch-x.y.z.tar") === USAGE === Enabling snitch is as simple as calling ‘snitch-mode’ interactively, or ‘(snitch-mode +1)’ from your init file. Initialization does very little, so this is safe to call in your Emacs init without worrying about deferral or negative consequences on startup time. The minimum required initialization is simply: > (require 'snitch) > (snitch-mode +1) An example initialization using ‘use-package’ might look like so: > (use-package snitch > :config > (snitch-mode +1)) snitch then runs in the background, performing its duties according to your configuration, and logging in its dedicated buffer. You may add firewall exception rules manually, as covered in the CONFIGURATION section below. Alternatively, you can also build filters with a guided UI by switching to the firewall log buffer (‘*snitch firewall log*’), highlighting an entry that you wish to filter on, and execute ‘M-x snitch-filter-from-log’. This launches a popup window that allows you to configure a new filter based on one or more fields of the selected log line, and add it to either your blacklist or whitelist. To disable snitch, call ‘snitch-mode’ interactively, or ‘(snitch-mode -1)’ programmatically. You can restart snitch with ‘snitch-restart’. === CONFIGURATION === Customize snitch with ‘M-x customize-group snitch’, or manually in your Emacs initialization file. Most users will have five variables that need to be configured before use: - ‘snitch-network-policy’ -- whether to allow or deny network connections by default. - ‘snitch-process-policy’ -- whether to allow or deny subprocesses by default. - ‘snitch-log-policy’ -- which events to log (to see the options, run ‘M-x describe-variable snitch-log-policies’) - ‘snitch-network-*list’ -- filter rules containing exceptions to the default network policy. See FILTER RULES below. Use ‘-whitelist’ if the default policy is ‘deny’, or ‘-blacklist’ if the default policy is ‘allow’ - ‘snitch-process-*list’ -- filter rules containing exceptions to the default process policy. See FILTER RULES below. Use ‘-whitelist’ if the default policy is ‘deny’, or ‘-blacklist’ if the default policy is ‘allow’ Have a look in ‘snitch-filter.el’ for examples of black/whitelist filters, and in ‘snitch-test.el’ for contrived examples of pretty much everything. ==== COMMON CONFIG: DENY ==== A useful configuration is to deny all external communication by default, but allow certain packages to communicate. This example demonstrates permitting only the ’elfeed’ package to create network connections: > (use-package snitch > :config > (setq snitch-network-policy 'deny) > (setq snitch-process-policy 'deny) > (setq snitch-log-policy '(blocked whitelisted allowed)) > (add-to-list 'snitch-network-whitelist > (cons #'snitch-filter-src-pkg '(elfeed))) > (snitch-mode +1)) ==== COMMON CONFIG: ALLOW + AUDIT ==== Another useful configuration is to allow all accesses, but log them to keep an audit trail. This might look like so: > (use-package snitch > :config > (setq snitch-network-policy 'allow) > (setq snitch-process-policy 'allow) > (setq snitch-log-policy '(allowed blocked whitelisted blacklisted)) > (setq snitch-log-verbose t) > (snitch-mode +1)) ==== FILTER RULES ==== Filter rules, as specified in ‘snitch-(process|network)-*list’ variables, are specified as cons cells where the car is a filtering function, and the cdr is a list of arguments to pass to the function in addition to the event object: > (setq snitch-network-whitelist > '( > (filter-fn1 . (argQ)) > (filter-fn2 . (argN argP)) > )) Each filter function should have a prototype accepting EVENT as the snitch event object in consideration, and ARGS as the list of arguments from the cdr of the rules entry: > (defun filter-fn1 (event &rest args)) EVENT is an eieio object defined by ‘snitch-network-entry’ or ‘snitch-process-entry’, and inheriting from ‘snitch-source’. A trivial function which matches if a single string in the event object matches a known value might look like so: > (defun filter-fn1 (event name) > (string-equal (oref event proc-name) name)) While a more complex filter function might treat ARGS as an associative list of key/value pairs: > (defun filter-fn2 (event &rest alist) > (cl-loop for (aslot . avalue) in alist with accept = t > do > (let ((evalue (eieio-oref event aslot)) > (val-type (type-of avalue))) > (unless (cond > ((eq val-type 'string) (string-equal avalue evalue)) > (t (eq avalue evalue))) > (setq accept nil))) > when (null accept) > return nil > finally return accept)) The return value of a filter function determines whether the filter should take effect. t means "take effect" and nil means "do not take effect". What that means for the event depends on which list the filter rule is in. If the rule is in a whitelist, t means allow and nil means block. If it is in a blacklist, t means block and nil means allow. ==== HOOKS ==== Events are passed to user-provided hook functions, if specified. These hooks can subscribe to receive events either immediately on arrival, upon a final decision, or both. The hooks can change snitch’s final decision. Hook functions take two arguments, the type and the event object: > (defun snitch-hook (type event)) TYPE is one of `snitch-hook-types', and corresponds with the names of the hook lists. This argument is provided so you can define one function which can be used in several hooks. EVENT is an eieio object defined by ‘snitch-network-entry’ or ‘snitch-process-entry’, and inheriting from ‘snitch-source’. Hooks should return t to allow snitch to continue processing as it would have, or return nil to reverse snitch’s decision. For hooks in ‘snitch-on-event-functions’, returning nil cancels all further processing of the event and blocks it immediately. For other hook lists, returning nil reverses the action implied by the list name: returning nil in a ‘snitch-on-allow-functions’ hook causes the event to be blocked, returning nil in a ‘snitch-on-block-functions’ hook causes it to be allowed. snitch also supports filtering log entries with hooks via ‘snitch-log-functions’. These hooks can pass, block, or modify entries before they are printed in the snitch log. See ‘M-x describe-variable snitch-log-functions’ for details. snitch also calls hooks when it starts (‘snitch-init-hook’), shuts down (‘snitch-deinit-hook’), or opens or closes the log filter window (‘snitch-log-filter-window-open-hook’, ‘snitch-log-filter-window-close-hook’). === PERFORMANCE === Performance has not been measured, and should not be assumed to be particularly good. Nothing is currently optimized. Memory usage should not be particularly high, as events are ephemeral and only contain a small amount of metadata. The largest use of memory is the audit log, which does keep copies of all events in the log. This can be controlled via ‘snitch-log-buffer-max-lines’. Firewall rules are traversed linearly, and short-circuit (if an early rule terminates processing, the subsequent rules will not be considered). To optimize for performance, the total number of rules should be kept to a minimum, and most likely to match rules should be added earlier in the lists. === TIMER TRACING === Since snitch’s usefulness is highly dependent on the ability to trace back to the original source that triggered an event, Emacs timers pose a bit of a challenge. Timers are used to trigger network requests asynchronously, but have the side effect of losing the stack trace back to the function or package that initiated it. To deal with this, snitch optionally supports timer tracing. When tracing is enabled, by customizing ‘snitch-trace-timers’ to t, snitch hooks into Emacs’s timer functions, and records backtraces whenever a timer is registered. If a timer later generates a snitch-relevant event, snitch concatenates the regular backtrace with the cached timer backtrace to get a full call stack for the event. As an example, here are two snitch log entries when opening RSS feeds with the elfeed package, which uses timers for web requests: With ‘snitch-trace-timers’ set to nil (tracing disabled): > [2020-12-07 21:32:56] (allowed) -- #s(snitch-network-entry \ > 1607373176.6757963 \ > timer-event-handler \ > /usr/share/emacs/27.1/lisp/emacs-lisp/timer.el \ > site-lisp \ > www.smbc-comics.com www.smbc-comics.com 443 nil) Notice how the source is the function ‘timer-event-handler’ in ‘timer.el’, part of the special ‘site-lisp’ package? *All* timer-originated network calls appear to originate from that function, since it is the lowest level Emacs timer dispatch function. It is impossible to filter on the true source. Now with ‘snitch-trace-timers’ set to t (tracing enabled): > [2020-12-07 21:33:06] (allowed) -- #s(snitch-network-entry \ > 1607373186.6863618 \ > elfeed-insert-html > /home/trevor/.emacs.d/elpa/elfeed-20200910.239/elfeed-show.el \ > elfeed \ > www.smbc-comics.com www.smbc-comics.com 443 nil) For this event, snitch has successfully traced through the timer to find the true source, ‘elfeed-insert-html’ in the ‘elfeed’ package! Timer tracing comes with a cost: snitch has to generate metadata for every single timer event. If your Emacs usage involves a very large number of timers, or very high-frequency timers, snitch’s tracing could lead to delays and inflated memory usage. Consider carefully whether this is a feature you need, and leave it disabled if you will not use it, or if you experience any performance issues while running snitch. You can run ‘snitch-monitor-unique-timer-fns’ to get a sense of which timers are currently active. After running that function, there will be a 60 second delay, followed by printing the names of all timers that were active during the minute and the number of times they fired. Similarly, if you run with timer tracing enabled for a while, you can use ‘snitch--debug-print-timer-state’ to print a summary of how many timers snitch has intercepted, and how many saved backtraces are currently active in memory. === SECURITY === snitch provides, effectively, zero security. If you were to ask your Principal Security Engineer friends, they might say that an effective security boundary must be "tamper-proof" and provide "complete mediation." snitch does neither. Tamper-proof: none at all. Any other Emacs package can simply disable snitch, or modify it to pass malicious traffic undetected. Complete mediation: no attempt has been made to verify that *all* network and subprocess accesses must go through the functions that snitch hooks. Given the complexity of Emacs, it is extremely unlikely that they do. However, your Principal Security Engineer friends also like to blather on about ’defining your security model’, and a fun game to play with them is to define your security model such that none of the insecurities are in it. As so: Security model: includes malicious adversaries snitch effectiveness: zero. Security model: includes no malicious adversaries snitch effectiveness: great! snitch is useful for auditing and blocking unwanted features in an otherwise well-behaving ecosystem. It is handy for getting a record of exactly what your Emacs is doing, and for fine-tuning accesses beyond Emacs’s boundaries a little bit better. It will not, however, save you from the bad guys. === KNOWN LIMITATIONS === When snitch blocks events, some Emacs functions that seldom throw errors in normal use will throw errors because of snitch. It is very likely that blocked connections will cause errors to bubble up in strange and unexpected ways, as many package authors have not handled these exceptional cases. snitch does not intercept domain name resolution (DNS). snitch has a strong preference for identifying user-provided packages as the "originating source" of events. Events that you may consider as originated in built-in/site-lisp code may be attributed to a user package instead, if one is higher up in the backtrace. For instance, `helm' may often show up as the source if installed, since `helm-M-x-execute-command' is often somewhere in the stack. snitch has not been tested with IPv6. snitch has not been tested with inbound connections. In theory, it can prevent the creation of a listening socket. Once a socket is open, though, it would not be able to monitor incoming connections to the socket. === TODO === - send notifications in batches? - interactive prompts? - handle service strings as port numbers - ensure the inverted negation rules make sense - add blacklist for timer functions - profit! === VERSION HISTORY === v0.3.1 (development) v0.3.0 (2021-02-02) - published on MELPA - make snitch a global minor mode - introduce (snitch-mode) - make (snitch-init) private (snitch--init) - make (snitch-deinit) private (snitch--deinit) - add init and deinit hooks - customizable keymap for log filter wizard - fixed several byte compiler warnings v0.2.0 (2020-12-09) - first published version v0.1.0 (before 2020-12-09) - Initial development and testing - Network and process firewall functionality - Audit logging - Whitelist + blacklist filtering - Backtrace processing - Timer backtrace expansion - User event and logging hooks - ert test framework ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2, or (at your option) any later version. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along with this program; see the file COPYING. If not, write to the Free Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin Street, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301, USA. ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;